Occupied or Lent Property in Italy: Get It Back and Sell

Occupied or Lent Property in Italy: Get It Back and Sell

You lent your home in Italy to a son or daughter, a relative or a friend. Or you found it occupied by someone with no right to be there. Now you want it back, perhaps to sell it. Italian law applies, whatever your nationality and whatever the rules in your own country. This guide explains what an owner can do and how a property that is not vacant can be sold.

1. Free loan or unlawful occupation: the key difference
A comodato is a free loan of property (art. 1803 Italian Civil Code). Someone who moved in with your consent is a borrower (comodatario), not a squatter. It is not a tenancy: no rent is paid and the rules are different. If the borrower does not give the house back when due, he stays without any right, but getting him out is a civil matter.
Unlawful occupation is different: someone enters or settles in your home without any agreement. Here criminal law also comes in (point 4).
Practical advice: put a comodato in writing, with a clear term or purpose. A verbal agreement is valid, but harder to prove in a dispute.

2. When you can ask for the house back

  • No fixed term (comodato precario): the borrower must return the house as soon as the owner asks (art. 1810). If there was a set term, the occupant must prove it: a verbal agreement with no proven term is a comodato precario, even if the occupant has meanwhile carried out works to make the house habitable (Court of Pavia, judgment no. 532 of 5/06/2026).
  • A term or a specific use: the house comes back when the term expires or the use ends. Earlier only if the owner has an urgent and unforeseen need (art. 1809).
  • A house lent to a son or daughter to live in with their family: be careful. Italian courts tend to treat such a loan as tied to the family's needs, so it cannot simply be ended on request. If, after a separation, a judge assigns the home to the parent living with the children, it gets more complex. Take advice from an Italian lawyer first.

3. How to recover the house from a borrower
1. A written request for return, by registered letter with return receipt or certified email (PEC), with a reasonable deadline to leave. Any compensation also runs from this request (point 5).
2. Mediation. For disputes about a comodato, mediation is compulsory before going to court (art. 5(1) Legislative Decree 28/2010). An agreement on the leaving date and costs is often reached there.
3. Court action for return. The fast eviction procedure (convalida di sfratto, arts. 657-658 Code of Civil Procedure) is for leases: a comodato needs an ordinary court action. With the judgment, the court bailiff (ufficiale giudiziario) can enforce the handover if needed.
Time and cost depend on the court and the case, which is why an agreement, when possible, is almost always the best solution.

4. If the house is unlawfully occupied
Since 2025 the Italian Criminal Code has a specific offence: arbitrary occupation of property used as another person's home (art. 634-bis Criminal Code, introduced by Decree-Law 48/2025, converted by Law 80/2025). It is punished with two to seven years' imprisonment when someone, by violence or threat, occupies or holds the home or its appurtenances without right, or prevents the owner from returning. The same penalty applies to anyone who takes the property by deception or hands it over to others. Prosecution requires a complaint (querela) by the victim.
The same decree introduced a fast procedure to restore possession (art. 321-bis Code of Criminal Procedure). At the prosecutor's request, the judge orders the owner's reinstatement. If the occupied house is the complainant's only actual home, the police can order immediate release, subject to confirmation by a judge within short deadlines.
Two warnings. The offence requires violence or threat (or deception, for taking the property): a former borrower who simply stays on does not normally fall under it, and the civil route applies. And never take matters into your own hands by changing the locks or cutting the utilities: you could end up in the wrong.

5. Compensation for occupation
The Joint Divisions of the Italian Supreme Court (Cassazione, judgment no. 33645 of 15/11/2022) held that the owner is entitled to compensation when he loses the concrete possibility of using the house, himself or by letting it. He must state it specifically, but may prove it by presumptions. If the exact amount cannot be proved, the judge sets it on an equitable basis, also using market rent as a reference. For lost profit, such as a missed letting or sale, the specific lost opportunity must be proved.

6. Can you sell an occupied or lent property?
Yes. A comodato is an agreement between the parties and does not bind the buyer: according to the Cassazione (judgment no. 664/2016), the new owner can end the borrower's use at any time, but compensation for occupation runs from when he asks for the house back, not from the date of the deed (rogito). A lease is different: a lease with a certain date (data certa, a date provable against third parties) before the sale binds the buyer (art. 1599 Civil Code). So does a court order assigning the family home, once recorded in the property registers.
In practice there are two options.

  • Vacate before selling. This brings more buyers, including those with a mortgage, and a better price.
  • Sell with the occupant. It is possible, but it must be stated clearly in the listing and in the preliminary contract (compromesso), with documents. The pool of buyers shrinks: many buyers, and almost all foreign buyers, want vacant possession at completion, and the price reflects it.

A common middle way: in the compromesso the seller undertakes to hand over the house vacant at completion and, if in doubt, part of the price is held in deposit by the notary until the house is vacated.

If you live abroad
A power of attorney signed before a notary, in favour of someone you trust in Italy, saves many trips between the request, mediation and the deed. The Italian notary (notaio) is a public official acting for the whole transaction, not a solicitor representing one side; for a dispute with an occupant you need an Italian lawyer (avvocato).

How we work
Since 2003 Aquamarina Real Estate has helped owners and buyers in Sanremo, Bordighera and across the Riviera di Ponente. When you ask us to sell a property that is not vacant, we first find out who lives there and on what basis, collect the documents and assess with you whether to vacate first or sell as it is. For the legal side we refer you to a lawyer.
Want to know what your property is worth, vacant or occupied? Request a free valuation, call +39 0184 26.16.87, email info@aquamarina.email or visit our offices in Sanremo (Via Roma 32) or Bordighera (Via Vittorio Emanuele 302).

Read also: Who can stay in the home you buy in Italy? · Selling property on the Italian Riviera: price, time and mistakes

This guide is for information only and does not replace advice from a lawyer or notary.

Request informations

Fill out the form

By submitting this form I confirm that I have read the privacy notice.

Chat Whatsapp Chat Whatsapp